The other shoe dropped for the Pirate Bay today (news here, and for the first act, see The Pirate Bay: Standing Up In Court For a Generation of Blackbeards). The four co-defendants were each found guilty of being accessories to copyright infringement in a Swedish court. The court’s documents say that the Pirate Bay co-founders helped promote theft and so they’ve each been sentenced to 1 year in prison and fined $3.5 million ($14m total). If the judgment stands, maybe the next files they’ll be looking to share in secret will be in a cake.

Sweden had already been strengthening its reputation for being hard on piracy since they recently began requesting that local internet service providers log all the IP addresses of computers involved in file sharing starting at the beginning of this month. Consequently, Swedish internet traffic has fallen by over 30% (see this BBC article). If something similar were to be enacted in the U.S., it could be decried as further infringement on our right to privacy and it wouldn’t be tolerated well at all.

Much is going to be made about this Swedish court decision and the forthcoming appeals in the short term, but it’s hard to predict if the outcome is really going to deliver much of a blow to file sharing in general until the stigma of copyright transgressions is something that’s educated effectively to scoffing young users.

The Pirate Bay is akin to a fleet of off-shore gambling boats floating in international waters. Even while the main defendants are caught up in Swedish courts, the operations can and probably will continue under the supervision of other affiliated groups. And it’s not like the Navy can escort our copyrighted materials. So, while this news is fresh validation for the media rights holders, it’s still not the end of the battle.

- Michael Gaudet